What if my Goof Proof Protection Plan claim was denied, and I want to file a dispute? December 18, 2020 15:53 Updated To dispute the denial of your Goof Proof Protection Plan claim, it would be best to contact us. Please have the following account information ready: Phone number Email Customer ID Related articles What accidents are covered by Goof Proof? What is considered an accident? What is Goof Proof? Who is Guardian? Why does my furniture have to be fixed? Why can’t I just get a new item?