What if my Goof Proof Protection Plan claim was denied, and I want to file a dispute? December 18, 2020 15:53 Updated To dispute the denial of your Goof Proof Protection Plan claim, it would be best to contact us. Please have the following account information ready: Phone number Email Customer ID Related articles What accidents are covered by Goof Proof? How can I confirm if I already purchased a Goof Proof Protection Plan to protect my furniture? What is Goof Proof? What is considered an accident? How do I look up the status of my Customer Care support ticket?